How to Choose Mechanical Keyboard vs Membrane Keyboard?

Mechanical Keyboard VS Membrane Keyboard

 

Some of you may know little about the mechanical keyboard. You may ask what’s the differences between mechanical keyboards and membrane keyboards. How a mechanical keyboard benefits me? Here are your answers.

Membrane Keyboard 

 

The primary point you should know is what is the membrane keyboard, or PC keyboards. Generally, our laptops have a membrane keyboard.

 

How does it work?

 

There are three main parts to construct a membrane keyboard: top membrane layer, “holes” layer, and the bottom membrane layer. Conductive traces are contained in the top membrane layer and a bottom membrane layer, working as a connector. When you press a key, the conductive traces bridge the “holes” layer and send a signal to the parent device.

Pros

• More Affordable

A membrane keyboard is significantly cheaper than a mechanical keyboard. Here is not talking about a big brand like Logitech, which membrane keyboard is also very expensive.

 

• Quiet

Normally, membrane keyboards are quieter than mechanical keyboards. Membrane keyboards have no clicking sound. People who prefer keeping the working environment quiet may prefer a membrane keyboard. There is no interruption to your colleagues. However, some mechanical keyboards with Brown or Red switches can also be applied for office. The sound can barely be heard.

 

• Portable

Membrane keyboards regularly weight less than mechanical keyboards. There are some ultra-light, ultra-portable wireless membrane keyboards, which are easy to pack and at the same time they are rather expensive.

Cons

• Lifespan

Compared with mechanical keyboards, membrane keyboards easily wear out. The keys are likely to get sticky and affect the typing speed and accuracy.

 

• Typing experience

The keys can be sticky after a time of using. It gets hard to press when it’s old. It makes your typing experience not pleasant. After a long time of typing, your fingers could be painful.

 

• Cleaning

Cleaning a membrane keyboard is a difficult task. Because the keycaps can’t be removed, it requires lots of effort and time. It gets annoying sometimes.

Mechanical Keyboard

 

What is a mechanical keyboard?

A mechanical keyboard features with springs and switches for each key. Once you press a key, you actually activate its switch, and the keyboard sends a signal to the computer. In other words, these key switches are the souls of mechanical keyboards. For various applications and user preference, there are different key switches to choose, such as Brown Switch is the best typing mechanical switch.

 

Mechanical keyboards first appeared in the 1980s, but it soon replaced by the rubber dome keyboards in the 1990s. However, mechanical keyboards have upgraded the whole industry in every way. A mechanical keyboard is superior to a membrane keyboard in almost every aspect.

Pros

• Typing speed & accuracy

Velocities mechanical keyboards are the best typing mechanical keyboards in 2018. Mechanical keyboards will speed up your typing and improve accuracy. Because of the spring beneath each key, the keys are easy to press. You can type faster and more accurate. Some mechanical keyboards feature with “N-key rollover”, meaning you can press N keys at the same time and they will all be sent. Velocifire mechanical keyboards are designed for typing and work that all adopted with Brown switches that have the perfect force to press. Brown switches are the most suitable for typing. For more particular descriptions for switches, you can read our next article on switches. Even after a long time of typing, your fingers are not painful. Once you are used to a mechanical keyboard, it’s hard to go back to membrane keyboards.

 

• Durability

Mechanical keyboards use a hard switch instead of a membrane, which makes mechanical keyboards last longer than membrane keyboards. Every key works separately and can be easily replaced after a disruption. Keys won’t pop out easily like membrane keyboards. A good mechanical keyboard can last for years. A best typing mechanical keyboard must be excellent in durability.

 

• Customization

You can customize your mechanical keyboards as you wish. Because the keycaps can be removable, you can DIY your keycaps according to your preference.

 

• Addiction

At first, you may be not used to typing with a mechanical keyboard, but after a time you will fall in love with the typing feel. The Greek feeling and an incredible typing experience get you addicted.

 

• Easy to clean

Removable keycaps make the mechanical keyboards super-easy to clean. You can remove the keycaps totally and clean them. It takes less time and effort.

 

• Backlight

Most mechanical keyboards have backlight: sharpness, brightness, and adjustability. You can adjust the brightness of backlight according to your needs.

Cons

• Louder

Generally, a mechanical keyboard is louder than a membrane keyboard because of the key switches. The sound depends on which type is used in the keyboard. In a working environment, the noise may disrupt your colleagues. However, some switches, such as the Browns and Reds are quite quiet. Velocifire mechanical keyboards are all adopted with Brown switches that are super appropriate for offices or school computer labs. A best typing mechanical keyboard must fit in working conditions.

 

• Heavier

Mechanical keyboards are normally heavy and well-built. Some people are fond of the heaviness because it keeps the keyboard at a particular position. In the meanwhile, it makes mechanical keyboards hard to carry.

 

• Expensive

Mechanical keyboards are normally more expensive than membrane keyboards. The premium materials, switches, and technique all add the cost. Velocifire offers high-qualified mechanical keyboards at an affordable price. More people are capable of owning a well-built Velocifire mechanical keyboard, so a best typing mechanical keyboard doesn’t have to be expensive.

 

• Key chattering

There is a chance that key chattering happens when the dust gets into your switches. When you press “A”, you get “aaa”. Luckily, it’s very easy to clean a mechanical keyboard. Key chattering can be avoided effectively.

Related Reading: How to Select A Mechanical Keyboard – Complete Guide (2019 Updated)

Recommended Items